In case some of you didn’t notice, there has been a war being waged between Blu-Ray and HD-DVD, the two competing formats for HD movies. Having recently purchased a 32″ Toshiba HD TV, I have been following the war fairly closely and wanted to give you a report from the battlefield.
The Basics
Blu-Ray is certainly the superior format. It holds more information and those studios that have been releasing Blu-Ray movies have been using DolbyHD for the sound, as opposed to DolbyDigital for HD-DVDs. DolbyHD is a lossless codec and is far superior to DolbyDigital.
That being said, HD-DVD has offered more features on the discs, with more interactivity and online features (many of the players have ethernet jacks).
The Players
Seeing the obvious strengths of the Blu-Ray platform (there is nothing stopping Blu-Ray discs from having the same features of HD-DVD discs), many studios have started releasing their movies exclusively on Blu-Ray. The most recent convert is Warner Studios, leaving only Universal and Paramount as HD-DVD exclusives. Paramount is most likely committed to HD-DVD for another year, while Universal’s future is up in the air.
Key software/video game monoliths like Sony (who invented Blu-Ray) and Apple have shown their support for Blu-Ray, while Microsoft has released an HD-DVD player for the XBox. However, recent reports have shown that Microsoft may be more open to Blu-Ray than previously thought.
Buying Advice
Blu-Ray will most likely win the HD War, especially with the recent (January 5) switch of Warner Studios from HD-DVD to Blu-Ray. However, Blu-Ray players are still prohibitively expensive. My advice? Amazon.com has a great sale on HD-DVD players right now. You can get a good Toshiba (the inventor of the HD-DVD platform) HD-DVD player for under $200 plus 10 free HD-DVD movies valued at $20 a pop.
The HD-DVD player will upconvert your standard DVDs to HD-like quality (Blu-Ray does this too, but it is still an expensive alternative), you’ll get to see HD movies for cheap, and, if and when Blu-Ray wins, you’ll see huge clearances on HD-DVD movies. At that time, you can buy a Blu-Ray player that hopefully resolves some of the slow load times associated with current Blu-Ray players and use your HD-DVD player as a good, HD movie player in another room.